Pin it
When bread cubes soak up sweet custard and get dusted with cinnamon sugar, ordinary French toast transforms into magical bite-sized treasures. These tiny golden nuggets pack all the cozy flavors we love about regular French toast but come in fun, popable form that'll brighten any breakfast table. Each little morsel gets wonderfully crisp outside while staying soft and custardy inside - exactly what makes them so impossible to resist.
I whipped these up when my grandkids stayed over last Sunday. That amazing cinnamon smell filled my kitchen, and they couldn't wait to start munching. Even my breakfast-skipping hubby couldn't help snagging a few while I was putting them on plates.
Key Components
- Chunky bread: Forms the base of these treats - try brioche for extra richness, challah for beautiful texture, or Texas toast for something hearty
- Eggs: Hold everything together, add protein, and create that signature custardy middle
- Whole milk: Gives the fat needed for that gorgeous golden outside
- Vanilla extract: Boosts sweetness without fighting with the cinnamon
- Ground cinnamon: Adds cozy warmth to every bite
- Regular sugar: Gets a bit caramelized during cooking for extra flavor depth
- Butter: Adds that can't-beat-it richness and helps get that perfect golden color
Making Irresistible Morsels
- Cutting Your Bread:
- Dice your favorite bread into one-inch squares that'll soak up the egg mix without falling apart. Slightly stale bread actually works better since it soaks up more flavor without turning mushy.
- Mixing The Egg Bath:
- Beat eggs and milk until they're completely blended, then mix in vanilla, cinnamon and salt. It should be fluid but thick enough to coat a spoon. Let each bread cube take a quick dip - long enough to soak up flavor but not so long it turns to mush.
- Cooking To Perfection:
- Warm your pan to medium and drop in a good chunk of butter. When it starts to foam slightly, toss in your soaked bread chunks. Keep them moving with a wooden spoon so all sides get nicely browned. As they cook, the wet outside turns into a delicate crust while the inside stays soft and custardy.
- Adding The Sweet Stuff:
- While they're still hot, toss the cooked pieces in cinnamon sugar. The warmth helps the sugar stick perfectly, creating that sweet coating that reminds you of cinnamon donuts but without all the deep frying.
Pin it
My grandma always told me to use day-old bread for French toast, saying that was her secret trick for the best texture. Now when I make these little bites, I think about her kitchen and how she showed me that simple ingredients often make the most unforgettable meals. When the sugar hits those warm little cubes and starts to caramelize just a bit, it takes me right back to those special mornings cooking with her.
Morning Meal Makeover
These tasty morsels fit into any breakfast setup. Serve them with fresh fruit and yogurt for a well-rounded morning meal. They're also show-stoppers at brunch gatherings, especially when set out in little paper cups with tiny forks. For something extra special, try setting up a French toast bite station with different dips and toppings for everyone to customize their own.
Taste Adventures
- Try switching up your bread for totally different flavor experiences. Hawaiian bread adds a touch of tropical sweetness while cinnamon raisin bread kicks up the spice factor.
- Mix some orange zest into your egg mixture for bright citrus notes that work beautifully with cinnamon.
- For grown-ups only, splash a bit of bourbon or rum into the custard mix for a sophisticated twist that makes these treats dessert-worthy.
Storing Your Treats
Pop any leftover bites in a container with parchment paper between layers so they don't stick together. They'll stay good in the fridge for two days, though the cinnamon sugar might get a bit moist. Don't microwave them when reheating or they'll turn soggy. Instead, put them on a baking sheet in a warm oven for about five minutes until they're heated through and slightly crisp again. A toaster oven works great for small batches and uses less power.
Pin it
I'd been making regular French toast for years before I stumbled on this bite-sized version, and it completely changed my breakfast routine. There's something just so fun about these little perfectly-sized morsels that makes everyone at my table smile. The way they combine that familiar comfort-food taste with a fresh, modern presentation keeps me coming back to this recipe whenever I want to make an everyday morning feel special.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make Cinnamon Toast Bites with regular soft bread?
- Sure, but soft bread might not hold its shape well. Thicker or crusty bread works better.
- → Why is day-old bread the go-to for this?
- Bread that’s a bit stale soaks up less liquid, avoids a soggy middle, and stays cubed when cooked.
- → Can I prepare Cinnamon Toast Bites ahead of time?
- They’re tastiest right after cooking. They can lose their crisp texture if made too early.
- → What other sauces can I serve with these besides syrup?
- Besides maple syrup, try chocolate drizzle, caramel, fruit sauce, or just sprinkle on powdered sugar.
- → How should I store leftovers, and can I reheat them?
- Keep leftovers in a sealed container in the fridge for up to 2 days, and reheat briefly in a toaster oven.